What Booking.com really costs your guesthouse (and how to win those guests back)
- Benjamin Smith
- 3 days ago
- 5 min read
Table Of Contents
A booking drops into your inbox at eleven at night. Two nights, the room with the good view, a couple who sound lovely in their little message. For a second it feels great. Then comes the part nobody talks about, the quiet sum you do in your head where you work out how much of that booking you actually get to keep.
If it came through Booking.com or one of the other big sites, the answer is usually somewhere between 15 and 25 percent less than the guest paid. On one stay that stings a little but across a full season it can be the difference between a year that works and a year that just about holds on.
The number behind the number
Say a couple books two nights at £120 a night, so £240 in total, at 18% commission you hand back a little over £43 before you have washed a single towel. Do that forty times across a summer and you have given away the better part of two thousand pounds, for guests who were coming to your town anyway. (Those figures are just an example. Your own rate is whatever your contract says, which is worth digging out and reading properly, because plenty of owners genuinely do not know their real number off the top of their head.)
Here is the thing that took me years to feel rather than just know, the commission is only half of what you lose. The bigger loss is the guest themselves because the booking site keeps the relationship, not you. You rarely get their real email or phone number, so the next time they fancy a few days in your part of the world you are quietly hoping they remember your name, rather than doing what most people do, which is open the same app and book whatever comes up first. You paid to win that guest once, without a way to reach them, you will very likely pay to win them again.
That is the real trap underneath the commission. It is not a one-off fee, it is a toll you keep paying on the same people.
You are freer than you think
A lot of owners assume the big sites forbid them from offering a better price anywhere else. The rules around that have loosened a great deal in the UK and Europe in recent years. In practice you have far more room than you imagine to reward someone for booking with you directly, and you do not even have to fight on headline price. A free late checkout, a proper breakfast included, a bottle of something from a local maker waiting in the room, these cost you very little and they feel generous in a way a faceless platform never will. Worth checking your own agreement so you know exactly where you stand as most independents are leaving easy wins on the table here.
Five ways to win more direct bookings
None of this means turning your back on the big sites. For most independents they are how a good number of new guests find you in the first place, which is genuinely useful. The aim is simpler than ripping up your listings, treat a platform booking as an introduction, then bring the relationship in house so the next stay comes straight to you.
1. Make booking direct the better deal, then make sure people actually know it. A small saving or a thoughtful extra, mentioned warmly at checkout and printed somewhere they will see it, does the job. Guests are not loyal to Booking.com, they just go where it is easy and cheap, so quietly be both.
2. Own the welcome and the whole stay. The hours a guest spends in your breakfast room, relaxed and well looked after, are the best chance you will ever get to turn a one-night transaction into someone who comes back for years. That is a human job long before it is a technology one, it also happens to be the thing independents are already brilliant at.
3. Get their email the natural way, not a form nobody fills in. The ordinary moments do it, the confirmation you send yourself, the quick note to check they found the place alright, the thank you after they leave. Each one is a chance to become a name they recognise rather than a room number on an app.
4. Hand them an easy way back. A friendly direct booking link in a guest's hands just after a good stay, while they still feel warm towards the place, does more than any advert ever will. This is the piece I leaned on hardest when I built IntuitiveStay, a direct booking win-back that invites a happy guest to come straight back to you next time instead of paying the toll all over again. It is not clever, it just makes the obvious thing effortless.
5. Be the place they actually remember. People forgive a lot when they feel genuinely looked after. They tell their friends, who then book direct because that is the name they were given. Word of mouth is the one channel that costs no commission at all and it runs entirely on how you made the last person feel.
Start small and count it
You do not need a new website or a clever system to begin. Pick one of those five and do it on your very next checkout, then keep a simple count of how many guests come back to you directly over the following months. Even a handful a season changes the shape of your year, because every direct booking is money that used to leave the building and now stays in it.
The part the big platforms cannot copy
A guest will put up with a faceless booking on a faceless site but what they remember, the thing that brings them home to you, is how a place made them feel. That is the one advantage you hold that no global platform can buy or fake. It is exactly why the independents who look after people properly can win back far more of their own bookings than they ever expected.
So this week, dig out your real commission rate and look at it honestly, then choose one small change and make it. The big sites will keep sending you guests but you simply do not have to keep renting the same ones back forever.
IntuitiveStay alleviates this problem even if you forget. By being a part of IntuitiveStay, everytime a guest leaves your property and chooses to leave their email, IntuitiveStay automatically sends them a direct win-back email reminding the guest to book directly with you next time for a cheaper rate.
Comments